Blog

In recent years, there has been a growing global interest in hydrogen as a clean and sustainable energy source. With its potential to revolutionize various sectors, including transportation and energy production, hydrogen is increasingly seen as a key player in the transition to a low-carbon future. However, as the world explores the vast potential of hydrogen, it is essential to address the associated hydrogen risks and challenges that come with its production, storage, and utilization.

As hydrogen technologies gain momentum, insurance companies are closely examining the implications and risks involved in insuring hydrogen-related projects and infrastructure. Insurance providers play a critical role in assisting industries and stakeholders in managing risks, evaluating safety measures, and ensuring financial protection in the event of accidents or incidents.

Type of Hydrogen Technology

There are generally two types of hydrogen available in the market:

1. Grey hydrogen: This is the most commonly produced type of hydrogen, and it is produced from natural gas through a process called steam methane reforming. Grey hydrogen is the cheapest type of hydrogen, but it generates significant carbon emissions during production.
2. Green hydrogen: This type of hydrogen is produced using renewable energy sources such as wind, solar, or hydro power through a process called electrolysis. Green hydrogen is considered a clean and sustainable fuel because it does not generate any carbon emissions during production. However, it is currently more expensive to produce than grey hydrogen due to the high cost of renewable energy.

There are also other types of hydrogen such as blue hydrogen, which is produced from natural gas but with carbon capture and storage, and turquoise hydrogen, which is produced from natural gas using a different process that generates less carbon emissions than grey hydrogen. However, these types of hydrogen are not yet widely available in the market.

What technology being used for Grey and Green hydrogen?

The main technology used for producing grey hydrogen is steam methane reforming (SMR), which is a process that uses high-temperature steam to react with natural gas, producing hydrogen gas and carbon dioxide (CO2) as a byproduct. The process involves the following steps:

1. Natural gas is mixed with steam and heated in a high-temperature reactor, typically between 700-1000°C.
2. The steam reacts with the natural gas, producing hydrogen gas and carbon dioxide.
3. The hydrogen gas is separated from the carbon dioxide using various separation technologies, such as pressure swing adsorption or membrane separation.
4. The separated hydrogen is then purified and compressed for use as fuel.

The technology used for producing green hydrogen is electrolysis, which is a process that uses an electric current to split water molecules into hydrogen and oxygen. The process involves the following steps:

1. Water is fed into an electrolyzer, which contains two electrodes.
2. An electric current is applied to the electrodes, causing the water to split into hydrogen and oxygen.
3. The hydrogen gas is then separated from the oxygen using various separation technologies, such as pressure swing adsorption or membrane separation.
4. The separated hydrogen is then purified and compressed for use as fuel.

Electrolysis can be powered by renewable energy sources such as wind, solar, or hydro power, making green hydrogen a clean and sustainable fuel source with no carbon emissions. However, the cost of producing green hydrogen is currently higher than that of producing grey hydrogen due to the high cost of renewable energy.

What are the risks of these type of hydrogen?

Like any energy source or technology, both grey and green hydrogen come with certain risks that need to be taken into consideration. Some of the major risks associated with hydrogen include:

1. Safety risks: Hydrogen is highly flammable and can ignite easily, which can pose a safety risk if proper handling and storage procedures are not followed. Additionally, hydrogen leaks can occur during production, storage, or transportation, which can be hazardous to workers and the public.
2. Cost risks: Producing hydrogen can be expensive, particularly for green hydrogen, which requires renewable energy sources such as wind or solar power. The high cost of production can make hydrogen less competitive compared to fossil fuels or other renewable energy sources.
3. Environmental risks: Grey hydrogen production generates significant carbon emissions, contributing to climate change and air pollution. Additionally, the production and transportation of hydrogen can have environmental impacts, such as habitat destruction, water pollution, and land use changes.
4. Technical risks: The technologies used to produce, store, and transport hydrogen are still developing and may not be fully mature or proven at large scales. Technical failures or malfunctions could lead to accidents, leaks, or other safety concerns.
5. Regulatory risks: Regulations and policies related to hydrogen production and use can change over time, which could impact the viability and profitability of hydrogen projects.

In summary, while hydrogen has the potential to be a useful and sustainable energy source, there are risks associated with its production, storage, and use that need to be managed and mitigated.

What is underwriters view on hydrogen project risks? Why underwriters do not deploy their full capacity to underwrite hydrogen projects?

There are a few reasons why underwriters may not deploy their full capacity to underwrite hydrogen projects:

1. Lack of historical data: Hydrogen projects are a relatively new and emerging sector, and there may not be a lot of historical data available on which to base risk assessments. Underwriters may be hesitant to deploy their full capacity until more data is available to assess the risks associated with hydrogen projects.
2. Technical complexity: Hydrogen projects can be technically complex and may involve multiple stakeholders, technologies, and regulatory requirements. Underwriters may require specialized knowledge and expertise in order to assess the risks associated with these projects, which may limit their capacity to underwrite them.
3. High risk perception: Although hydrogen projects can offer significant opportunities for growth and innovation, they can also be perceived as high-risk due to their potential safety, technical, and environmental risks. Underwriters may be cautious in deploying their full capacity to underwrite these projects until they are confident that the risks can be effectively managed and mitigated.
4. Limited demand: Despite the potential opportunities associated with hydrogen projects, there may be limited demand for insurance or financing in this sector, which can limit the capacity of underwriters to deploy their full capacity.

Overall, underwriters may be cautious in deploying their full capacity to underwrite hydrogen projects due to the sector’s technical complexity, limited historical data, and perceived risks. However, as the sector continues to mature and more data becomes available, underwriters may become more comfortable deploying their full capacity to support the growth of hydrogen projects.

Challenges faced by insurers in assessing and underwriting hydrogen-related projects

1. Understanding Hydrogen Risks:
   To effectively manage risks, insurance companies need a comprehensive understanding of the hazards associated with hydrogen. This includes evaluating potential dangers such as leaks, explosions, and fire risks, as well as assessing the safety protocols and regulations in place to mitigate these risks.
2. Safety Standards and Regulations:
   Insurance companies closely scrutinize the adherence of hydrogen projects to safety standards and regulatory frameworks. Robust safety measures, industry guidelines, and compliance with international standards are crucial factors in determining the insurability of hydrogen initiatives.
3. Risk Mitigation and Loss Prevention:
   Insurers work closely with project developers, manufacturers, and operators to identify risk mitigation strategies. This involves assessing the design and engineering aspects of hydrogen infrastructure, evaluating safety protocols, and ensuring adequate emergency response plans are in place.
4. Technological Advancements and Research:
   The evolving nature of hydrogen technologies necessitates continuous research and development. Insurance companies actively monitor technological advancements to stay updated on safety improvements, reliability enhancements, and risk mitigation innovations within the hydrogen sector.
5. Collaboration and Knowledge Sharing:
   Insurance companies facilitate knowledge sharing and collaboration among stakeholders in the hydrogen industry. This includes sharing risk assessment insights, best practices, and lessons learned to promote safer practices and support the growth of the hydrogen market.
6. Insurance Products and Coverage:
   Insurers are developing specialized insurance products tailored to the unique risks associated with hydrogen. These products encompass property insurance, liability coverage, business interruption insurance, and environmental liability policies, providing comprehensive protection for hydrogen-related projects.
7. Encouraging Investment and Market Growth:
   Insurance companies play a vital role in instilling confidence among investors and lenders by offering coverage against potential risks. By providing financial protection, insurers help foster investment in hydrogen infrastructure, driving the growth of the industry and supporting the transition to a greener and more sustainable future.

As hydrogen gains traction as a viable solution for decarbonization, insurance companies are actively engaging with the associated risks and challenges. Through a thorough understanding of hydrogen risks, collaboration with industry stakeholders, and the development of specialized insurance products, insurers are enabling the safe and sustainable growth of the hydrogen sector. By effectively managing risks and providing financial protection, insurance companies contribute to the realization of a cleaner, more resilient, and energy-diverse future powered by hydrogen.